REBEL Core Cast 118.0 – IM vs PO NSAIDs
Bottom Line Up Top: There is no difference in analgesic efficacy between oral and intramuscular NSAIDs.
Clinical Scenario: A 34-year-old woman presents to the ED with back pain. After your history and physical, you conclude that the patient’s pain is muscular in origin and likely secondary to heavy lifting while moving apartments. You contemplate analgesic options and decide that a NSAID makes sense. Should you give her PO ibuprofen or IM ketorolac?
What Your Gut Says: Give the ketorolac IM. IM ketorolac will provide better pain relief and the patient will be happier with her care since she got an ‘injection’ and, after all, she did come all the way to the hospital.
What The Evidence Says: Unlike with many areas of medicine, there is ample evidence to answer this question and most of that evidence has been around for a couple of decades. Reviewing every study would be tedious and, fortunately, we’ve got a great review article on the topic. One important thing to understand is that the different NSAIDs have widely accepted equianalgesic doses; at the right dose, all NSAIDs (whether it be naproxen, ibuprofen, ketorolac or diclofenac) give equivalent pain relief (Irizarry 2021). This allows us to look at studies with the different NSAIDs and compare them to each other.
A 2007 review of the literature concluded that there was no difference in analgesia between IM ketorolac and PO ibuprofen (Arora 2007). The study included a number of high-quality research studies:
|
Study |
Format |
Comparison |
Findings |
Notes |
|
Retrospective analysis of prospectively collected data. |
PO Ibuprofen 800 mg vs IM ketorolac 60 mg |
No difference in analgesic effect. |
Ibuprofen superior secondary to cost, ease of administration + lack of pain w/ administration. |
|
|
Double-blind RCT |
PO Ibuprofen 800 mg vs IM ketorolac 60 mg |
No difference in analgesic effect. |
Similar onset of action in mild-moderate pain. |
|
|
Double-blind RCT |
PO Ibuprofen 800 mg vs IM ketorolac 60 mg |
No difference in analgesic effect. |
||
|
Double-blind RCT |
PO Ibuprofen 800 mg vs IM ketorolac 60 mg |
No difference in analgesic effect. |
Surgical Patients |
|
|
Double-blind RCT |
IM diclofenac 75 mg vs PO diclofenac 100 mg |
Small difference favoring IM in terms of speed to pain relief |
Authors conclude PO superior due to time to prepare injection |
The data looks fairly clear in terms of analgesic efficacy but, don’t some patients simply prefer to receive a shot? While this dogmatic claim is often made, the data doesn’t appear to support it.
Schwartz and colleagues performed an ingenious trial (Schwartz 2000)
- Enrolled 64 ED patients with acute pain.
- Treatment arms:
- Oral group: Orange drink (800 mg ibuprofen) + placebo “ibuprofen” pill
- Injection group: Orange drink (800 mg ibuprofen) + placebo “ketorolac” injection
- Essentially, all patients got the same analgesic medication (the orange drink) thinking it was just some juice and an inert study placebo (pill or injection).
- No significant difference in analgesia between the two groups.
Bottom Line: Just give the NSAID by mouth. IM NSAIDs may provide slightly faster time to analgesia but, IM dosing comes with the cost of injection, pain , a longer time to prepare the dose and more intensive nursing resources to administer the medication. As long as the patient’s gut works, oral NSAIDs provide similar analgesic effects to IM dosing and should be the preferred route of administration.
Bonus Pearls:
- IM injection of ketorolac causes significant pain. If the patient can’t take PO, be kind and pop in an IV.
- The ceiling pain relief dose for ketorolac is 15 mg IV (Motov 2017).
Read More
REBEL EM: The Ketorolac Analgesic Ceiling
References
Irizarry E et al. A randomized controlled trial of ibuprofen versus ketorolac versus diclofenac for acute, nonradicular low back pain. Acad Emerg Med 2021; 28(11): 1228-35. PMID: 34133820
Arora S et al. Myth: Parenteral ketorolac provides more effective analgesia than oral ibuprofen. Can J Emerg Med 2007; 9(1): 30-2. PMID: 17391598
Wright JM et al.. NSAID use and efficacy in the emergency department: single doses of oral ibuprofen versus intramuscular ketorolac. Ann Pharmacother 1994;28:309-12. PMID: 8193414
Turturro MA et a. Intramuscular ketorolac versus oral ibuprofen in acute musculoskeletal pain. Ann Emerg Med 1995;26:117-20. PMID: 7618770
Neighbor ML et al. Intramuscular ketorolac vs oral ibuprofen in emergency department patietns with acute pain. Acad Emerg Med; 1998; 5(2): 118-122 .PMID: 9492131
Mixter CG et al. Preemptive pain control in patients having laparoscopic hernia repair: a comparison of ketorolac and ibuprofen. Arch Surg 1998;133:432-7. PMID: 9565125
Qureshi I et al. Intramuscular versus oral diclofenac for acute pain in adults with acute musculoskeletal injuries presenting to the ED setting: a prospective, double-blind, double dummy, randomised controlled trial. 2019; 36: 401-6. PMID: 31217178
Schwartz NA et al. Patient’s perceptions of route of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug administration and its effect on analgesia. Acad Emerg Med 2000; 7: 857-61. PMID: 10958124
Motov S et al. Comparison of intravenous ketorolac at three single-dose regimens for treating acute pain in the emergency department: a randomized controlled trial. Ann Emerg Med 2017; 70(2): 177-84. PMID: 27993418
Post Peer Reviewed By: Salim R. Rezaie, MD (Twitter/X: @srrezaie)
